Surgery vs. Laser Treatment for Varicose Veins: Which is Right for You?
Sitting across from me in the clinic is one of my patients, Neha, a bright, energetic woman in her 40s, who had been enduring her varicose veins silently for far too long.
“Doctor, I’ve read about surgery, but then I heard about laser treatments. I’m so confused!” she sighed, voicing the same dilemma many of my patients face. Surgery has been around for years, but laser treatments seem less invasive.
The confusion between the two options is common, and in today’s world of advanced medical technology, it’s no wonder.
Neha’s concern resonated deeply with me because so many people—just like her—are unsure about which treatment to choose.
Is traditional surgery the best option? Or has laser treatment overtaken surgery as the go-to solution?
As a vascular surgeon with years of experience treating varicose veins, I have seen firsthand the pros and cons of both. And today, I’m here to break it down for you.
By the end of this article, you’ll know exactly what varicose vein stripping surgery and laser treatments entail, their risks, costs, and—most importantly—why doctors like myself are recommending laser treatment more and more.
What is Varicose Vein Stripping Surgery?
Varicose vein stripping surgery has been a staple in treating varicose veins for decades. It’s a relatively straightforward procedure in which the affected veins are “stripped” out of the leg through small incisions. The primary goal is to remove the malfunctioning veins, ensuring that blood is rerouted through healthier veins. This surgery is typically reserved for more severe cases where veins are large, twisted, and causing significant discomfort or health risks.
During the surgery, the patient is usually placed under general anesthesia or spinal anesthesia. The surgeon makes two or three incisions, one near the groin and another at the calf or ankle. A flexible wire is inserted through these incisions to pull out the damaged vein. While the procedure is effective, it comes with the usual risks associated with surgery, such as infection, scarring, and a longer recovery time.
While it’s been the traditional method of treatment for severe varicose veins, varicose vein stripping surgery is gradually being replaced by less invasive techniques like laser treatment. But before we get into that, let’s explore all the surgical options for treating varicose veins.
What Are the Available Surgical Varicose Vein Treatments?
Apart from vein stripping, there are a few other surgical options to treat varicose veins:
- Ambulatory Phlebectomy: In this procedure, small punctures are made in the skin, and the varicose veins are removed piece by piece. It’s typically performed under local anesthesia, and while it’s effective, the recovery can still take several weeks.
- Vein Ligation: This involves tying off the affected veins to prevent blood flow into them. This is often done in conjunction with vein stripping or as a standalone procedure.
While these surgical options can be effective, many patients and doctors are turning towards newer, minimally invasive alternatives like laser treatment.
Complications of Surgical Varicose Vein Treatments
Though surgery is a well-established treatment for varicose veins, weighing the potential complications is important. Some of the common risks associated with surgical varicose vein treatments include:
- Infection: As with any surgery, there’s always the risk of infection, especially around the incision sites.
- Scarring: Surgical treatments often leave noticeable scars, which can be a concern, especially when treating veins on the legs.
- Longer Recovery: Patients who undergo surgery typically face a more extended recovery period, often needing several weeks to return to their regular routine fully.
- Pain and Swelling: Post-surgical pain and swelling can last longer than with less invasive treatments.
This brings us to a critical question: Is surgery always necessary? Or could laser treatment offer the same, if not better, results with fewer risks?
What is Laser Vein Treatment?
Laser treatment, also known as Endovenous Laser Treatment (EVLT), is a now-established and revolutionary approach to treating varicose veins. It has quickly gained popularity due to its minimally invasive nature and short recovery time. The laser procedure uses heat from laser energy to collapse and seal the varicose veins, allowing the body to reroute blood flow through healthier veins naturally.
Here’s how it works: A small laser fiber is inserted into the affected vein through a tiny incision. The laser emits energy that causes the vein to collapse and eventually get absorbed by the body over time. The procedure is done under local anesthesia and typically takes under an hour.
Laser treatment is often recommended for patients with less severe varicose veins, but it’s also effective for treating larger veins. The beauty of this treatment lies in its precision and efficiency.
Why Doctors Recommend Laser Treatment Over Surgery
There’s a reason why laser treatment for varicose veins is becoming the preferred option for many doctors and patients. Here are some key advantages:
-
- Minimally Invasive: Laser treatment doesn’t involve large incisions unlike traditional surgery. This means less scarring, fewer stitches, and a quicker recovery time. Most patients can resume their normal activities within a day or two.
- Reduced Risk of Complications: Because general anesthesia or large incisions are not needed, the risks of complications like infection or nerve damage are significantly lower.
- Shorter Procedure Time: The procedure is relatively quick, typically lasting under an hour. It’s often performed in a doctor’s office rather than a hospital setting, making it convenient for patients.
- Minimal Pain: Patients report less post-procedure pain and swelling compared to surgery. Since the procedure is done under local anesthesia, discomfort is kept to a minimum.
Moreover, when you consider the varicose veins laser treatment cost in India, it’s often more affordable than you might think. The varicose laser treatment cost is competitive compared to surgery, especially when factoring in the shorter recovery time and fewer post-operative visits.
About Dr. Sumit Kapadia
As a leading vascular surgeon in India, I’ve spent years honing my skills in treating varicose veins using both surgical and non-surgical methods. With the rise of minimally invasive techniques like endovascular surgery and laser treatments, I’ve seen firsthand how these advanced options can change a patient’s life—helping them return to pain-free living quickly and effectively.
At my practice, I prioritize personalized treatment plans, helping patients like Neha understand their options and make informed decisions. Whether you’re dealing with mild varicose veins or a more severe case, my team and I are here to guide you to the best possible outcome.
FAQs
Surgery recovery takes 2-4 weeks, while laser treatment recovery is much quicker—typically 1-2 days.
Laser treatment is minimally painful and done under local anesthesia or regional anesthesia, with only mild discomfort afterward.
The cost ranges from INR 70,000 to INR 1,50,000, depending on the severity and type of room/ hospital.
Both are effective, but laser treatment is less invasive, has fewer risks, and has quicker recovery, making it more popular in most cases.
Yes, laser treatment offers long-lasting results, though lifestyle changes are important to prevent recurrence.
While treated veins don’t come back, new varicose veins can form, especially if risk factors remain. The average rate of recurrence is 10 to 15%
Most patients can return to daily activities within 24-48 hours after laser treatment. However, exertional activities like walking, running and exercises can be resumed after 3 to 4 weeks of treatment.
So, which is better: surgery or laser treatment for varicose veins? The answer depends on the severity of your varicose veins and your personal preferences. While surgery remains a viable option for severe cases, laser treatments are fast becoming the treatment of choice due to their minimally invasive nature, reduced complications, and quicker recovery.
If you’re considering treatment for varicose veins, it’s essential to consult with a qualified vascular surgeon in India to discuss your unique situation. Whether you’re worried about the varicose veins laser treatment cost or simply want to know which treatment will give you the best results, I’m here to help. At the end of the day, the goal is the same—to get you back on your feet, living pain-free, and feeling confident.
